The Best Carbon Steel and Cast Iron Pans of 2026: Lodge, Smithey, Made In, de Buyer

Quick answer: the best cast iron skillet for most kitchens is still the Lodge 12-inch at $30, and the best carbon steel pan is the Made In 12-inch, which replaces a nonstick pan for eggs and fish. If you want cast iron that is lighter and smoother, the Lodge Blacklock; if you want cast iron that is beautiful, the Smithey No. 12. For the pro's carbon steel, the de Buyer Mineral B. And the Le Creuset Signature skillet is the one that goes from stove to table without seasoning.
Our picks at a glance:
- Best Cast Iron: Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet
- Best Lightweight Cast Iron: Lodge Blacklock 10.25-Inch
- Best Heirloom Cast Iron: Smithey No. 12
- Best Design: Finex 10-Inch
- Best Carbon Steel: Made In Carbon Steel Frying Pan
- Best Pro Carbon Steel: de Buyer Mineral B 11-Inch
- Best for Searing: Mauviel M'Steel 12.5-Inch
- Best Budget Carbon Steel: Merten and Storck 12-Inch
- Best Pre-Seasoned: OXO Obsidian 12-Inch
- Best Enameled Cast Iron: Le Creuset Signature Skillet 11.75-Inch
Every man should own one pan he can hand down, and it will be cast iron or carbon steel: both are a single piece of metal that gets better with every year of use, both go from burner to oven to grill, and both cost less than the nonstick pans people replace every eighteen months. We picked ten across both materials and every budget, from the Lodge that has been $30 since forever to the heirloom pieces from Smithey and Finex. If you are not sure which material you want, our cast iron vs carbon steel explainer settles it in five minutes and covers seasoning.
All ten work on induction. Sizes are the diameter across the top rim; cooking surface is typically two inches less.
| Pan | Material | Size | Weight | Surface | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet | Cast iron | 12 in | 8 lb | Pre-seasoned, pebbled | $30 |
| Lodge Blacklock 10.25-Inch | Cast iron, lightweight | 10.25 in | 4.6 lb | Triple-seasoned, smooth | $60 |
| Smithey No. 12 | Cast iron, polished | 12 in | 7.8 lb | Polished, pre-seasoned | $220 |
| Finex 10-Inch | Cast iron, polished, octagonal | 10 in | 6.5 lb | Polished, pre-seasoned, spring handle | $200 |
| Made In Carbon Steel Frying Pan | Carbon steel | 12 in | 3.9 lb | Seasoned or blue steel | $100 |
| de Buyer Mineral B 11-Inch | Carbon steel | 11 in | 4 lb | Beeswax coated, bare | $88 |
| Mauviel M'Steel 12.5-Inch | Carbon steel, heavy | 12.5 in | 5.3 lb | Beeswax coated, bare | $140 |
| Merten and Storck 12-Inch | Carbon steel | 12 in | 3.5 lb | Pre-seasoned | $60 |
| OXO Obsidian 12-Inch | Carbon steel | 12 in | 3.4 lb | Pre-seasoned, silicone sleeve | $70 |
| Le Creuset Signature Skillet 11.75-Inch | Enameled cast iron | 11.75 in | 7 lb | Black satin enamel, no seasoning | $275 |
1. Lodge 12-Inch Cast Iron Skillet: Best Cast Iron
Thirty dollars, made in Tennessee since 1896, and the most recommended pan in America because there is nothing to argue with: eight pounds of iron that holds heat like a brick, a pre-seasoning that is ready for bacon on day one, two pour spouts, and a helper handle. The surface is pebbled rather than polished, which does not affect cooking once the seasoning builds. It is the pan for steak, cornbread, skillet pizza, and forty years of Sunday breakfasts. $30 at Target.
2. Lodge Blacklock 10.25-Inch: Best Lightweight Cast Iron
The Blacklock is Lodge's answer to the boutique brands: a thinner casting that cuts the weight of a 10-inch skillet to 4.6 pounds, a smoother finish, a triple seasoning that is slick from the box, and a longer, cooler handle. It heats faster than the classic Lodge and retains a little less, which for a weeknight pan is the right trade. Sixty dollars for the closest thing to vintage cast iron you can buy new. $60 at Target.
3. Smithey No. 12: Best Heirloom Cast Iron
Smithey polishes its castings to a mirror in Charleston, South Carolina, which gives the No. 12 the glassy, naturally nonstick surface of a hundred-year-old Griswold with the heft of a modern pan. Three pour spouts, a helper handle with a leather sleeve option, a satin bronze color that darkens to black with use, and a lifetime guarantee. It is the pan that makes a stovetop look like a magazine. Buy it as the last cast iron pan you will own. $220 at Magnolia.
4. Finex 10-Inch: Best Design
Finex's octagonal skillet is the one everyone asks about: eight sides that make a pour spout in any direction, a polished cooking surface, a thick base that holds heat like a Lodge, and a coiled stainless spring handle that stays cool on the stove and looks like a piece of industrial art. It is made in Portland, Oregon, and it is heavy and expensive. It is also the only pan on this list that guests photograph. $200 at Target.
5. Made In Carbon Steel Frying Pan: Best Carbon Steel
Made In's carbon steel is what a lot of restaurant cooks now buy for home: a 12-inch pan made in France at 3.9 pounds, less than half a Lodge, with a flared shape that tosses and a riveted handle that stays cool. Buy the pre-seasoned version and it is ready for eggs on the first night; buy the blue steel version if you want to build the seasoning yourself. It sears like cast iron, heats in two minutes, and replaces nonstick permanently. $100 at AllModern.
6. de Buyer Mineral B 11-Inch: Best Pro Carbon Steel
The Mineral B is the carbon steel pan in French restaurant kitchens: a thick 3 mm sheet that holds heat better than thinner pans, a beeswax coating you wash off before the first seasoning, and a curved profile made for omelettes and crepes. The riveted handle is angled for a flip. Season it three times, cook a few pounds of bacon in it, and by the end of the month eggs slide off it like a nonstick. It is under $90 and it will be in the family for decades. $88 at Wayfair North America.
7. Mauviel M'Steel 12.5-Inch: Best for Searing
Mauviel has made pans in Normandy since 1830 and the M'Steel is its heavy carbon steel: thicker than the Made In, with more heat retention for searing a thick steak or a whole spatchcocked chicken, a long riveted handle, and a 12.5-inch diameter that feeds four. It is the carbon steel pan that behaves most like cast iron. Testers keep naming it the best carbon steel pan overall; we put it here because searing is what it does best. $140 at Target.
8. Merten and Storck 12-Inch: Best Budget Carbon Steel
Sixty dollars buys a 12-inch German-designed carbon steel pan that comes pre-seasoned, weighs 3.5 pounds, and performs within a hair of pans costing twice as much. The handle is a bit long, the seasoning needs a couple of weeks to become truly slick, and neither will matter after the first month. It is the carbon steel pan to buy if you are not sure you will like carbon steel, and most people who buy it never buy the expensive one. $60 at Target.
9. OXO Obsidian 12-Inch: Best Pre-Seasoned
OXO's carbon steel comes with a factory seasoning that is actually slick, which makes it the pan for anyone who does not want to run the oven for three hours before cooking. It is light at 3.4 pounds, the removable silicone sleeve keeps the handle cool on the stove and comes off for the oven, and the flared sides toss vegetables well. Treat it like the others once the factory coating wears in and it will last as long as any of them. $70 at JCPenney.
10. Le Creuset Signature Skillet 11.75-Inch: Best Enameled Cast Iron
The Le Creuset skillet is cast iron with a black satin enamel cooking surface, which means no seasoning, no rust, no fear of tomato sauce, and a pan that goes from the burner to the table in a color that matches the Dutch oven. It sears nearly as well as bare iron and cleans up with soap and a sponge. It is the pan for the kitchen where the pan is part of the decor, and Le Creuset's lifetime warranty means it stays there. $275 at Belk.
The Bottom Line
Start with the Lodge 12 and the Made In carbon steel: sixty and a hundred dollars and every steak, egg, and skillet dinner is covered for life. Upgrade to the Smithey when you want a pan you are proud of, and add the Le Creuset for the dishes that go to the table. Then read our seasoning guide once, and never think about nonstick again. The pizza oven can wait until next month.
Keep reading: Cast iron vs carbon steel explained | Best pizza ovens | Best grilling gear | The Anthony Bourdain kit
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best cast iron skillet to buy?
The Lodge 12-inch is the best cast iron skillet for most people: $30, pre-seasoned, made in the USA and nearly indestructible. The Lodge Blacklock is the best lightweight option, and the Smithey No. 12 and Finex are the best polished heirloom skillets.
What is the best carbon steel pan?
The Made In 12-inch carbon steel frying pan is the best carbon steel pan for most kitchens: made in France, 3.9 pounds, available pre-seasoned, and excellent for eggs, fish and searing. The de Buyer Mineral B is the professional favorite, and the Merten and Storck is the best under $60.
Is carbon steel or cast iron better for searing?
Cast iron sears slightly better because its mass holds heat when a cold steak hits the pan. A heavy carbon steel pan like the Mauviel M'Steel comes close while heating faster and weighing less. For a thick steak, choose cast iron; for a thin steak or a stir-fry, carbon steel.
Do carbon steel pans need to be seasoned?
Most do. Bare pans from de Buyer and Mauviel ship with a beeswax coating that is washed off before seasoning with thin layers of oil baked at 450 to 500 F. Pre-seasoned pans from Made In, Lodge, Merten and Storck and OXO are ready to cook on, and the seasoning improves with use.
Can you use cast iron on an induction stove?
Yes. Cast iron and carbon steel are both magnetic and work on every induction cooktop. Enameled cast iron like Le Creuset works too. Lift rather than slide cast iron to avoid scratching the glass surface.
This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.